Home Login Create account Contact Help
Close

Login to your account

Other Options

Tags: Cars Environment Hybrid Science

Do Hybrid cars help the environment?

Hybrid cars are marketed as "environmental friendly". However, I heard some opinions saying that because of the heavy double-engine system and the batteries needed for the electric engine, those cars are rather heavy and thus consume much more fuel than actually needed for a car that size.

So, Are Hybrid cars environmental friendly?

...

BTW, this is probably why they are always big cars - I haven't seen a small Hybrid car...



Log in to post an argument Subscribe to feed
Rank order
Aye
Hybrid cars are environmental friendly
infidel argues...
Thu, 15 Nov 2007 by infidel
Rank 1. Average +1.0 ( 1 votes )
SOME hybrids are environmentally friendly. If we're speaking only of fuel consumption, then the small hybrids like Toyota Prius, Honda Insight, or Honda Civic get better mileage than most other cars on the road. The NiMH batteries used in today's Hybrids may not be the most ecological power storage solution overall, but manufacturers are moving towards Lithium-ion batteries which are recyclable and therefore even more environmentally friendly.

The confusion stems from larger hybrids which use the hybrid technology for performance boosts (acceleration, especially) rather than to improve fuel economy.
Alexandra argues...
Fri, 16 Nov 2007 by alexandra
Rank 2. Average 0.0 ( 0 votes )
In these temperatures, most electric motors will simply not bother to start!
No matter how fuel efficient a vehicle is, it will never equal the energy efficiency (per person) of mass transit. All the hybrid vehicles I have seen use their electric motor to start up the car....and this is where their beauty lies!

Where I live, winter mornings are dark and cold - and in January/February, early morning temperatures of -40 degrees (both scales) are not particularly surprising. In these temperatures, most electric motors will simply not bother to start!

So, by flooding the market with cars that rely on electric motors to start at -40 degree temperatures, you will significantly increase mass public transit ridership - and that is the best thing for the environment!
Nay
Hybrid cars are bad for the environment
infidel argues...
Mon, 19 Nov 2007 by infidel
Rank 1. Average +1.0 ( 1 votes )
Hybrid cars are only marginally more efficient than regular vehicles
According to a whitepaper [teslamotors.com] from the smarty-pantses at Tesla, Hybrid cars are only marginally more efficient than regular vehicles.
Alexandra argues...
Fri, 16 Nov 2007 by alexandra
Rank 2. Average 0.0 ( 1 votes )
people will be less likely to curb their diving habits
Not every hybrid is created equal.

While it is a good idea to reclaim energy loss due to breaking, not every hybrid out there does this (yet?). The 'plug-in hybrids' in particular can be misleading about their true 'energy cost'. Why? Because every time energy is converted from one form to another, there is considerable energy loss.

We still heavily rely on fossil fuels to generated our electricity (at least, in this part of the world, we do). There is an inherent loss of energy in this conversion. Then, electricity is lost along its distribution route. Once the car is 'plugged in', the energy is again transformed - and thus lost - as it is stored in the car's battery. Only then comes the bit where the stored energy drives the motor....and this is the only portion that is measurable.

This does not seem to be a significant improvement for the environment.... And since we are being told that driving these vehicles is ecofriendly, people will be less likely to curb their diving habits (please excuse the pun).
infidel argues...
Thu, 15 Nov 2007 by infidel
Rank 3. Average 0.0 ( 0 votes )
If 100% of the world drove today's Prius or Hybrid Civic, we'd still be 100% dependent on fossil fuels.